WE MEET AGAIN – HIGHGATE UNITED
Posted: Thu Oct 04, 2012 10:30 am
WE MEET AGAIN – HIGHGATE UNITED
Coleshill meet possibly their closest, fiercest and definitely their longest rivals, weather permitting, at Pack Meadow on Saturday 6th October.
Highgate were formed in 1948, ironically by a group of orphans from Father Hudson's Homes in Coleshill. They played in the South Birmingham League but in 1964 they joined the then Worcestershire Combination, later to become the Midland Combination, after moving to Tythebarn Lane.
Coleshill Town joined them in the Mid Com's top flight in 1975 and from then the two teams have met every year, apart from 2000/01 when Coleshill dropped into Div 1 for a season, and after all those years of trying, they even made the step up to the Alliance together.
In all Highgate spent 43 seasons in the Mid Com, winning the title 3 times, and playing more than 1600 games, outstripping Coleshill's 32 seasons and nearly 1200 games. Only Walsall Wood, Northfield, West Midlands Police and Knowle, who are all still playing in the Com, could compete with those figures.
In total the two teams have met 76 times, 72 league and four cup matches, with Highgate coming out on top. Indeed, records would suggest Highgate are a bit of a bogey side to Coleshill. In the last 20 meetings Town have only won four times, and even in the year that Coleshill finally lifted the Mid Com Title they lost to the Gate three times (once in the Challenge Cup). On the bright side, that year, after losing to the Gate at Pack Meadow, the Colemen then went on a 12 game unbeaten run to pip Highgate to the championship on the last day of the season.
Neither side have pulled up any trees since promotion to the Alliance and last season was a real struggle for both sides, Coleshill finishing 16th with 14 wins, four places and six points above Highgate in the third from bottom position with 12 wins, a relegation place this season.
This season Coleshill are just two places above Gate with two wins from their 10 games, and Highgate have just the one win from their 9 games.
RESULTS
Scorers indicated where known, many results unavailable.
2011/12
Midland Alliance
Highgate United 3-1 Coleshill Town
Scorer: Steve Hakner
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... php?t=1013
Coleshill Town 1-1 Highgate United
Scorer: Steve Hakner
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... php?t=1054
2010/11
Midland Alliance
Coleshill Town 1-3 Highgate United
Scorer: Chris Gumery
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=936
Highgate United 0-1 Coleshill Town
Scorer: Neil Kitching
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=954
2009/10
Midland Alliance
Highgate United 2-1 Coleshill Town
Scorer: Marvin Johnson.
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=801
Coleshill Town 0-3 Highgate United
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=784
2008/09
Midland Alliance
Highgate United 0-3 Coleshill Town
Scorers: Matt Robinson, Ben Porter, Rob Evans.
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=766
Coleshill Town 0-0 Highgate United
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=724
2007/08
Midland Combination Premier
Highgate United 3-1 Coleshill Town
Scorer: Matty Robinson
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=630
Coleshill Town 2-3 Highgate United
Scorers: Danny Carter, Matty Robinson.
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=682
Challenge Cup
Coleshill Town 0-2 Highgate United
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=657
2006/07
Mid Com Prem
Coleshill Town 1-1 Highgate United
Scorer: Kevin Wagstaff
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=460
Highgate United 0-2 Coleshill Town
Scorers: Josh McPherson, David Brush.
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=566
2005/06
Mid Com Prem
Coleshill Town 1-2 Highgate United
Scorer: Myrone Levy
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=457
Highgate United 0-0 Coleshill Town
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=362
2004/05
Mid Com Prem
Coleshill Town 1-1 Highgate United
Scorer: Kevin Wagstaff
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=336
Highgate United 3-1 Coleshill Town
Scorer: Kevin Wagstaff
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=308
2003/04
Mid Com Prem
Highgate United 0-1 Coleshill Town
Scorer: Dan Nixon
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=217
Coleshill Town 0-3 Highgate United
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=199
2002/03
Mid Com Prem
Highgate United 2-0 Coleshill Town
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=109
Coleshill Town 0-0 Highgate United
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... ic.php?t=9
2001/02
Home 1-2 Dwayne Mardenborough
Away 2-1 Chris Kavanaugh, Mat Marshall.
Challenge Cup 1-3 Ant McManus
1999/2000
Home 5-2 Ant McManus, Richard Cotter, Ben Usher.
Away 1-0 Mitchell Thompson
1998/99
Home 2-2 Tony Mathews, Ashley Frost
Away 1-6
1997/98
Home 0-4
Away 2-2
1996/97
Home 2-1 Ricky Smith, Mark Charnley
Away 2-1 Mark Charnley, Neil Frost
1995/96
Home 2-3 Loz Cairns, Dave Carmicheal
Away 2-0
1994/95
Home
Away 5-1 Jon Johnson, Jimmy Stafford, Jason Phillips 2.
1993/94
Home 0-1
Away 1-2
1992/93
Home 4-1
Away 2-0
1991/92
Home 2-2
Away 1-2
1990/91
Home 1-0 Malanaphy
Away Tues 16th April 1991 New Information Highgate 2-0 Coleshill
Challenge Cup
Home 1-1 John Taylor
Away Replay 2-3 Rosborough, Hickman
1989/90
Home 0-1
Away Tues 8th May 1990, last game of the season. New Information Highgate 3-0 Coleshill.
1988/89
Home 2-2 Neil Brady, Steve D'Arcy
Away 3-4 Rhodes, Paul Brady, John Taylor
1987/88
Home 1-1 Link New result just added
Away 1-3 McNaught
1986/87
Home
Away
1985/86
Home 2-2 Ian Paul, Mark Harris
Away
1984/85
Home
Away
1983/84
Home 3-1
Away 2-2 Easter Monday 23rd April 1984 New result just added.
1982/83 Unknown
1981/82 Unknown
1980/81 Unknown
1979/80 Unknown
1978/79 Unknown
1977/78 New Information Saturday 27th August Coleshill Town 0-1 Highgate United
1976/77 Unknown
1975/76 Unknown
ALL TIME RECORD
League
P72 W16 D12 L23 F70 A85 + 21 Unknown results.
Cup
P4 W0 D1 L3 F4 A9
All Time
P76 W16 D13 L26 F74 A94
NB. Three results added 24th October 2012. One added 6th Nov 2012. One added 7th Nov 2012
Coleshill meet possibly their closest, fiercest and definitely their longest rivals, weather permitting, at Pack Meadow on Saturday 6th October.
Highgate were formed in 1948, ironically by a group of orphans from Father Hudson's Homes in Coleshill. They played in the South Birmingham League but in 1964 they joined the then Worcestershire Combination, later to become the Midland Combination, after moving to Tythebarn Lane.
Coleshill Town joined them in the Mid Com's top flight in 1975 and from then the two teams have met every year, apart from 2000/01 when Coleshill dropped into Div 1 for a season, and after all those years of trying, they even made the step up to the Alliance together.
In all Highgate spent 43 seasons in the Mid Com, winning the title 3 times, and playing more than 1600 games, outstripping Coleshill's 32 seasons and nearly 1200 games. Only Walsall Wood, Northfield, West Midlands Police and Knowle, who are all still playing in the Com, could compete with those figures.
In total the two teams have met 76 times, 72 league and four cup matches, with Highgate coming out on top. Indeed, records would suggest Highgate are a bit of a bogey side to Coleshill. In the last 20 meetings Town have only won four times, and even in the year that Coleshill finally lifted the Mid Com Title they lost to the Gate three times (once in the Challenge Cup). On the bright side, that year, after losing to the Gate at Pack Meadow, the Colemen then went on a 12 game unbeaten run to pip Highgate to the championship on the last day of the season.
Neither side have pulled up any trees since promotion to the Alliance and last season was a real struggle for both sides, Coleshill finishing 16th with 14 wins, four places and six points above Highgate in the third from bottom position with 12 wins, a relegation place this season.
This season Coleshill are just two places above Gate with two wins from their 10 games, and Highgate have just the one win from their 9 games.
RESULTS
Scorers indicated where known, many results unavailable.
2011/12
Midland Alliance
Highgate United 3-1 Coleshill Town
Scorer: Steve Hakner
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... php?t=1013
Coleshill Town 1-1 Highgate United
Scorer: Steve Hakner
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... php?t=1054
2010/11
Midland Alliance
Coleshill Town 1-3 Highgate United
Scorer: Chris Gumery
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=936
Highgate United 0-1 Coleshill Town
Scorer: Neil Kitching
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=954
2009/10
Midland Alliance
Highgate United 2-1 Coleshill Town
Scorer: Marvin Johnson.
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=801
Coleshill Town 0-3 Highgate United
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=784
2008/09
Midland Alliance
Highgate United 0-3 Coleshill Town
Scorers: Matt Robinson, Ben Porter, Rob Evans.
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=766
Coleshill Town 0-0 Highgate United
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=724
2007/08
Midland Combination Premier
Highgate United 3-1 Coleshill Town
Scorer: Matty Robinson
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=630
Coleshill Town 2-3 Highgate United
Scorers: Danny Carter, Matty Robinson.
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=682
Challenge Cup
Coleshill Town 0-2 Highgate United
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=657
2006/07
Mid Com Prem
Coleshill Town 1-1 Highgate United
Scorer: Kevin Wagstaff
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=460
Highgate United 0-2 Coleshill Town
Scorers: Josh McPherson, David Brush.
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=566
2005/06
Mid Com Prem
Coleshill Town 1-2 Highgate United
Scorer: Myrone Levy
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=457
Highgate United 0-0 Coleshill Town
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=362
2004/05
Mid Com Prem
Coleshill Town 1-1 Highgate United
Scorer: Kevin Wagstaff
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=336
Highgate United 3-1 Coleshill Town
Scorer: Kevin Wagstaff
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=308
2003/04
Mid Com Prem
Highgate United 0-1 Coleshill Town
Scorer: Dan Nixon
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=217
Coleshill Town 0-3 Highgate United
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=199
2002/03
Mid Com Prem
Highgate United 2-0 Coleshill Town
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... .php?t=109
Coleshill Town 0-0 Highgate United
http://www.coleshilltownfc.co.uk/report ... ic.php?t=9
2001/02
Home 1-2 Dwayne Mardenborough
Away 2-1 Chris Kavanaugh, Mat Marshall.
Challenge Cup 1-3 Ant McManus
1999/2000
Home 5-2 Ant McManus, Richard Cotter, Ben Usher.
Away 1-0 Mitchell Thompson
1998/99
Home 2-2 Tony Mathews, Ashley Frost
Away 1-6
1997/98
Home 0-4
Away 2-2
1996/97
Home 2-1 Ricky Smith, Mark Charnley
Away 2-1 Mark Charnley, Neil Frost
1995/96
Home 2-3 Loz Cairns, Dave Carmicheal
Away 2-0
1994/95
Home
Away 5-1 Jon Johnson, Jimmy Stafford, Jason Phillips 2.
1993/94
Home 0-1
Away 1-2
1992/93
Home 4-1
Away 2-0
1991/92
Home 2-2
Away 1-2
1990/91
Home 1-0 Malanaphy
Away Tues 16th April 1991 New Information Highgate 2-0 Coleshill
Challenge Cup
Home 1-1 John Taylor
Away Replay 2-3 Rosborough, Hickman
1989/90
Home 0-1
Away Tues 8th May 1990, last game of the season. New Information Highgate 3-0 Coleshill.
1988/89
Home 2-2 Neil Brady, Steve D'Arcy
Away 3-4 Rhodes, Paul Brady, John Taylor
1987/88
Home 1-1 Link New result just added
Away 1-3 McNaught
1986/87
Home
Away
1985/86
Home 2-2 Ian Paul, Mark Harris
Away
1984/85
Home
Away
1983/84
Home 3-1
Away 2-2 Easter Monday 23rd April 1984 New result just added.
1982/83 Unknown
1981/82 Unknown
1980/81 Unknown
1979/80 Unknown
1978/79 Unknown
1977/78 New Information Saturday 27th August Coleshill Town 0-1 Highgate United
1976/77 Unknown
1975/76 Unknown
ALL TIME RECORD
League
P72 W16 D12 L23 F70 A85 + 21 Unknown results.
Cup
P4 W0 D1 L3 F4 A9
All Time
P76 W16 D13 L26 F74 A94
NB. Three results added 24th October 2012. One added 6th Nov 2012. One added 7th Nov 2012